Celebs & Scandals
Lesser-Known History
Local Expert Guide

Discover Hidden Gems in NYC That Visitors Walk Past Every Day

Most visitors know Midtown for its skyscrapers, bright lights, and busy avenues. But step a block or two away from the crowds and you’ll find a very different New York. This Midtown Manhattan walking tour explores the fascinating Turtle Bay history, hidden landmarks, and remarkable characters that helped shape the city.

For over two hours, Bill Schulz leads you through a neighborhood packed with unforgettable stories. Visit the building where Bernie Madoff orchestrated one of history’s biggest financial frauds, stand outside the steakhouse where John Gotti’s reputation as the “Teflon Don” was cemented, and discover the location behind one of Marilyn Monroe’s most famous movie scenes. Learn why so many artists, writers, politicians, and celebrities called Turtle Bay home. And if you’ve ever been curious about celebrity homes in NYC, this neighborhood has an extraordinary story to tell.

This isn’t just another NYC walking tour or sightseeing route. It’s a chance to explore the secret places in NYC that rarely make the guidebooks, from Revolutionary War connections to Cold War intrigue, Art Deco landmarks, and streets where presidents, movie stars, musicians, and billionaires all crossed paths. If you’re looking for a Manhattan walking tour that goes beyond the obvious, this is the one you’ll be talking about long after it ends.

Why You’ll Love This Tour

Visit the site of Marilyn Monroe’s most iconic movie scene
Discover where John Gotti became the “Teflon Don”
Explore streets once home to legendary actors, musicians, and writers
Learn how Bernie Madoff’s empire collapsed
Uncover Revolutionary War and Civil War stories hidden in Midtown
Experience Turtle Bay through the eyes of a longtime local

Click the Tabs to Find out More!

What You’re in For

Price

$50


Departure time

11am


Meeting point

The northside of PJ Clarke’s on 915 Third Avenue, New York, NY 10022, between 54th and 55th Streets


Availability

Every day


Duration

2 hours


Group size

Max. 20


Pro tips

  • Wear actual shoes. This is a walking tour and Turtle Bay has plenty of uneven patches and busy corners, so come prepared.
  • The nearest subway stops are 51st Street and Lexington for the 6 and E trains. Restrooms can be found inside nearby establishments along the route.

Included

The best tour you’ll ever get via a guide who has lived in said area for over 20 years.


Not included

Despite the neighborhood’s name? Turtles will not be provided. Particularly those of the teenage, mutant variety.


What to bring

  • Comfortable walking shoes
  • A sense of adventure

Participation requirements

Bill has spent decades covering New York and specializes in the stories most people walk right past. A longtime journalist and licensed sightseeing guide, he combines rarely-heard history, local knowledge, and a healthy sense of humor to bring Turtle Bay to life.

Why Turtle Bay?

Turtle Bay packs more remarkable stories into a few city blocks than almost anywhere else in Manhattan. Within this neighborhood you’ll find the building where Bernie Madoff ran his billion-dollar fraud, the steakhouse forever linked to John Gotti becoming the “Teflon Don,” and landmarks connected to both the Revolutionary War and a Confederate plot that nearly changed the course of the Civil War.

These same streets have long attracted presidents, artists, architects, writers, and entertainers. A single block has been home to Katharine Hepburn, Bob Dylan, and Stephen Sondheim, while Paul Newman, Scarlett Johansson, Kurt Vonnegut, I. M. Pei, Frank Sinatra, General Douglas MacArthur, Robert F. Kennedy, and many others all spent part of their lives here. One local landmark has even welcomed every U.S. President from Herbert Hoover through Barack Obama.

Bill has lived in Turtle Bay for years and spent decades writing about New York. He knows these streets because he’s walked them, researched them, and written about them. That’s what makes this neighborhood, and this tour, so special.

See What Our Tipsy Tourists Are Talking About

Interested in One of Our Private Tours Instead? Check These Out...